Thursday, March 27, 2025

Space & Physics: Supersymmetry's long fall from grace

March 27 — This week, supersymmetry's long fall from grace, the U.S. government's top UFO scientist, the global response to the briefly Earth-threatening asteroid 2024 YR4, and much, much more. Enjoy!

Lee Billings, Senior Editor, Space and Physics


Supersymmetry, long considered the golden child of theoretical physics, has officially lost its luster at the world's reigning particle accelerator

Oh, how the mighty have fallen.

Supersymmetry, a theory that predicts the existence of undiscovered "superpartner" particles for every known elementary particle, has dominated particle physics for generations. And for good reason: SUSY, as it's often called, has been widely seen as the best route to new discoveries beyond the standard model of particle physics, offering potential explanations for lingering mysteries like dark matter as well as possible paths forward on vexing problems like quantum gravity.

The trouble is, experimentalists have spent decades searching for SUSY's superpartners using various particle accelerators, only to come up empty. The most damning null results have come from CERN's Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the world's largest and most powerful particle accelerator. That's because production of the lightest superpartner particles predicted by the simplest versions of SUSY should've been within reach of the LHC's collisions after a major upgrade to the facility in 2015. Indeed, searching for evidence of supersymmetry was one of the main justifications for building the LHC in the first place. Yet, once again, no signs of superpartners have emerged from its studies—and particle physicists are recalibrating accordingly.

The latest sign of this is the news that the LHC's two largest SUSY-relevant experiments, ATLAS and CMS, have reorganized their internal working groups so that none now exclusively focus on the theory. You can read all about it in this week's top story. Although this arcane change may seem immaterial, and indeed SUSY research still takes place at the LHC, the dissolution of SUSY-dedicated working groups is a major blow against the once-dominant theory—and a sign that an ever-increasing contingent of the physics community is ready to move on.

Any declaration of SUSY's death would be premature, but the outlook isn't exactly rosy. Then again, neither is the outlook for big-budget particle physics in the absence of a "next big thing" to chase. Supersymmetry has helped fuel major investments in multibillion-dollar physics experiments, so if it's largely abandoned by particle physicists, what comes next? That's a question no shortage of researchers and policymakers are desperately seeking to answer.

Lee Billings

If you're enjoying this newsletter, dive deeper with a subscription to Scientific American.

Top Stories
A Near-Miss with a City-Killer Asteroid Highlights Gaps in Earth's Defenses

The threat from near-Earth asteroid 2024 YR4 may have subsided, but discoveries of other hazardous space rocks are set to soar as new observatories come online

The U.S. Government's Top UFO Scientist Has an Open Mind about Alien Visitation

Have you seen something inexplicable in the sky? Jon Kosloski, director of the U.S. Department of Defense's All-Domain Anomaly Resolution Office, wants to hear from you

Content brought to you by Scientific American Travel
Join Us for an Extraordinary Eclipse Experience

Take an unforgettable journey to witness the 2026 total solar eclipse from a semi-private ship. Surrounded by the shimmering sea, you'll feel the collective excitement as you watch totality approach with fellow science lovers and your trip leader, Senior Editor Clara Moskowitz. Learn More.

Abel Prize Goes to Pioneer Whose "Math Toolbox" Can Be Used to Describe the Natural World

Masaki Kashiwara, this year's Abel Prize winner, co-founded a new field of mathematics called algebraic analysis

Who Will Build the Next Giant Particle Collider?

The European physics laboratory CERN is planning to build a mega collider by 2070. Critics say the plan could lead to ruin

How 'Qudits' Could Boost Quantum Computing

"Qudits," the multi-dimensional cousins of qubits, could make quantum computers more efficient and less prone to error

Mini-Satellite Sends Encrypted Quantum Message a Record-Breaking Distance

Scientists in China have transmitted encrypted images a record 12,900 kilometers, paving the way for quantum messaging anywhere on Earth

Can Earth's Rotation Generate Electricity? Physicists Divided over Controversial Idea

Experiments suggest an unusual magnetic material could help harness energy from Earth's rotation. But not everyone is convinced


How Researchers Found a Greener Way to Make Fuel for Nuclear Fusion—By Accident

Researchers have found an environmentally safer way to extract the lithium 6 needed to create fuel for nuclear fusion reactors. The new approach doesn't require toxic mercury, as conventional methods do

NASA Astronauts Finally Return, Seals Hold Their Breath, and Penguin Poop Stresses Out Krill

In this week's news roundup, two NASA astronauts finally return to Earth after nine unexpected months in space, gray seals hold their breath for more than an hour, and penguin poop panics krill.

What Makes a Moon?

Defining the word "moon" is harder than you might think

What We're Reading
  • Inside Trump and Musk's Takeover of NASA | The New Yorker
  • Trump Admin Plans to Cut Team Responsible for Critical Atomic Measurement Data | WIRED
  • Momentum Is Building for Jared Isaacman to Become NASA Administrator | Ars Technica

From the Archive
Physicists Struggle to Unite around Future Plans

Over 10 days, researchers participating in the once-a-decade "Snowmass process" attempted to build a unified scientific vision for the future of particle physics

Scientist Pankaj

Watch SpaceX's history-making Fram2 astronaut mission return to Earth today

Watch live: SpaceX's Fram2 astronauts return to Earth | Artemis 2 astronauts reveal mission patch to honor 'AII...